A fiery feud has erupted in the world of OnlyFans, with Australian ad*lt content creator Annie Knight publicly criticizing fellow creator Sophie Rain for comments made about morality and earnings in the industry. Knight, known for her headline-grabbing stunts, called Rain’s remarks “completely bulls–t” and accused her of misleading fans about her content and income.
Check out this article to know how much you can earn from OnlyFans.
The Spark of the Conflict
The drama ignited when Sophie Rain, a 20-year-old OnlyFans star, appeared on the “Bangin Out” podcast in August 2025. During the interview, Rain distanced herself and her former Bop House collaborators from creators in the “competitive s*x” space, stating, “Everyone just immediately assumes that we do porn. I think the most that any of us has shown is a really scandalous bikini top.
We’re not doing what Bonnie Blue is doing.” Rain’s comments suggested that her content avoids explicit material, preserving her “morals” while still achieving massive financial success, reportedly earning $43 million in 2024 alone.
Knight, who has built a reputation for her unapologetic approach to explicit content, took issue with Rain’s statements. Speaking exclusively to Us Weekly, Knight expressed frustration, saying, “I’m really annoyed that Rain was suggesting anyone who does s*x work doesn’t have morals.
She’s creating even more stigma for people in the s*x work industry by claiming they lack morals and trying to create a divide between OnlyFans and s*x work.” Knight, who gained notoriety for sleeping with 583 men in six hours, argued that Rain’s remarks unfairly tarnish creators who embrace explicit content.
Accusations of Deception
Knight didn’t stop at addressing Rain’s moral commentary. She also accused Rain of “flat-out lying” about her earnings and the nature of her content. Rain has claimed to have earned $80 million in 18 months by posting only bikini photos, a figure Knight disputes as misleading.
“She’s creating an entirely false narrative which is teaching young women that if they join OnlyFans and post bikini photos, with no explicit content, they will make $80 million,” Knight told Us Weekly. “She’s lying about the type of content she creates, claiming she has only ever posted bikini photos when there are strip teases and full nudes featured on her page.”
Knight’s allegations align with skepticism from others, including NBA star Michael Porter Jr., who questioned the authenticity of Rain’s reported $82 million income, speculating that her account might be managed by someone else. Rain defended her earnings, stating, “I worked 14-hour days, answered every DM, edited every post. Nobody faked that grind.”
Defending Morals in the Industry
Knight, who reportedly earns $600,000 a month following her viral 583-men challenge, passionately defended her own moral compass. “I post explicit content and I have morals,” she told Us Weekly. “I believe in right and wrong, individuality, and sexuality, and everyone having a right to express themselves.”
Knight argued that Rain’s comments undermine creators who are transparent about their explicit work, adding, “She needs to have a look in the mirror because she’s essentially saying that she doesn’t have morals.”
The Australian creator emphasized the challenges of the OnlyFans industry, noting, “We face criticism every single day; it affects our family and friends. It’s a 24/7 job, creating hundreds of pieces of content per week.” Knight’s openness about her work, including her hospitalization after the 583-men event due to health complications, underscores her commitment to authenticity in a field often shrouded in stigma.
Rain’s Rise and Controversies
Sophie Rain, a Miami-born creator who rose to fame on TikTok before joining OnlyFans in June 2023, has positioned herself as a unique figure in the industry. Identifying as a Christian and claiming to be a virgin, Rain maintains that her “not-quite-R-rated” content aligns with her values, reportedly earning her $43 million in 2024, including $4.7 million from one loyal follower. “The Lord’s very forgiving, and he put me on here,” Rain told People in December 2024.
However, Rain’s claims have drawn scrutiny beyond Knight’s criticism. Her involvement in a tech scandal with former Astronomer CEO Andy Byron, who allegedly spent $40,000 on private video conversations, added fuel to debates about her authenticity. Despite this, Rain’s 11 million TikTok followers and her Bop House venture—a modern take on the Playboy mansion—have cemented her as a digital powerhouse.
The Bigger Picture
This feud highlights the ongoing tension within the OnlyFans community, where creators navigate public perception, personal values, and financial transparency. Knight’s outspoken critique challenges Rain’s narrative, urging fans to question the realities of success on the platform. As the debate rages on, it underscores the complexities of an industry that thrives on individuality yet faces constant scrutiny.
For now, Annie Knight remains unapologetic, advocating for honesty and respect in the s*x work industry, while Sophie Rain continues to defend her approach. The clash has sparked heated discussions online, with fans and critics weighing in on X, where sentiments range from support for Rain’s hustle to skepticism about her claims. OnlyFans remains a lightning rod for controversy, and this feud is unlikely to be its last.
This is Kyle Thomas, a professional writer, and a news editor. I started my career as a blogger who writes on various topics and then I decided that I should join a NEWS agency where I can work as a NEWS reporter. So, I joined a renowned agency in the town as an internet and after getting 2 years of experience, now I am working as a senior NEWS reporter for The Daily NEWS Times.
